The differentiation was real. It was also worth nothing.

Illustrative example. Fictional agency, fictional vendor, fictional numbers. No real solicitation, agency, or client is described.

The opportunity

A state agency issued an RFP for field data collection software used by program inspectors. About 600 users. A category where our product is genuinely better than the two names that usually win.

What Section M actually said

FactorPoints
Cost60
Technical approach25
Past performance15

The 25 technical points exist, and they are scored, which is the part that makes this look winnable on paper. What matters is how they cluster. The technical criteria are a checklist of required capabilities, and every credible bidder in this category meets all of them. In practice the technical scores land between 22 and 25 for anyone who is seriously bidding. The realistic swing is three points.

Sixty points decide it.

The arithmetic

Our list price is 22 percent above the regional average for this category, because the product does more and we do not discount to lose money. On a 60-point price factor, a 22 percent premium costs somewhere between eleven and fourteen points, depending on which price formula the agency ran, before anyone reads a page of technical.

To recover that gap you would need to win more than four times the technical spread that exists in this category, against criteria every competitor already satisfies. It cannot be done. The best written proposal in the room loses to a cheaper one that cleared the same checklist.

The decision

Do not pursue. Two weeks of writing to lose on arithmetic is two weeks not spent on the recompete we can win.

The note worth keeping

Price-weighted solicitations are not biased against good products. They are asking a different question, and the honest answer is that this buyer has decided capability is a commodity here. If that changes, the door reopens. Until then, bidding is a donation.

The discipline is not saying no to bad opportunities. It is saying no when the product is excellent and the evaluation cannot see it.

More bid or no-bid teardowns